Seven Inconvenient Truths About the 2009 H1N1 Flu
Pandemic
by Dr. Dana Myatt
"Selective reporting" about the H1N1 virus and
vaccine make it sound like getting a vaccination for the "pandemic flu" is a
no-brainer. Thinking men and women should know the under-reported scientific
conclusions and plain vanilla government statistics concerning this year's
"Panic-Demic" before making this seemingly simple but potentially
life-threatening decision.
To that end I present these "inconvenient truths" (fully referenced) for your
consideration. Please note that it is extremely politically incorrect to
question the value of the flu vaccine.
In Health,
Dr. Myatt
Seven Inconvenient Truths About the 2009 H1N1 Flu Pandemic
by
Dr. Dana Myatt
1.) What is a "Phase Six" Pandemic? (Probably NOT what You Think)
Contrary to popular thought (and most
dictionaries), "pandemic" does not mean "large numbers" in WHO / CDC language.
According to the World Health Organization's (WHO) Pandemic Phase Descriptions,
"pandemic" refers to distribution, not numbers or severity. Here is the WHO
criteria for pandemics:
-
A "Phase 4" pandemic
means only that a virus is transmissible between humans.
-
A "Phase 5" pandemic
means only that one viral disease has been seen in two countries.
-
A Phase 6 pandemic
means only that one viral disease has been seen in three or more countries.
Again, the term "pandemic" does NOT refer to numbers of people affected or
severity of the disease. (1)
For perspective, The WHO announced as of 20 September 2009 that there have
been 3917 total deaths worldwide from H1N1, on par with world-wide mortality
from any seasonal or other flu for this time of year. (2) Malaria kills an
average of 3,000 people every day in southeast Asia. (3)
2.) Is The H1N1 Flu Really a Danger to the U.S.?
Of less than 4,000 flu-related deaths world-wide, only 211 have occurred in
the US as of August 2009. (4) This represents a death total lower than from
seasonal flu for years 2005 through 2008 in the U.S. (5)
Adding H1N1 and seasonal flu together, flu-related deaths are still lower this
year compared to previous "non-pandemic" years.
Not only is the total flu rate lower this year in the U.S., but the H1N1 flu
has been much milder than predicted here and abroad. (6-10)
According to the WHO, most H1N1 infections are mild, occurring in numbers
comparable to seasonal flues, with fast recovery and mostly without need for
medical care. Mortality rates so far have been only a fraction of the number
of those reported each year from seasonal flu. WHO also acknowledges that
"Large outbreaks of disease have not yet been reported in many countries..."
(11)
Harvard researcher Mark Lipsitch, PhD, explained at an Institute of Medicine
meeting that on a 1 to 5 scale -- with 5 being a 1918-like pandemic -- this
swine flu pandemic is a 1. Deputy Director of the CDC's flu division, Daniel
Jernigan, MD, concurs. "We are likely to have numbers that look very similar
to what Dr. Lipsitch had," Jernigan said. (12)
3.) Why H1N1-related deaths are actually smaller than reported in the U.S.
As of August 2009, ALL flu-associated deaths in the U.S. are being reported
together. H1N1, seasonal flu and "influenza-like illness" (ILI) are added
together to give the "flu mortality rate." Reported illness and death totals,
now include "influenza-like illness" (ILI) that in some cases may not be any
form of flu at all. (13)
Other reports concede that a portion of reported H1N1 deaths have actually
been caused by pneumonia, not the H1N1 virus itself. (14)
Because the new reporting system tallies deaths from all types of flu, the
reported numbers of total flu deaths are not all attributable to H1N1. This
means the true H1N1 mortality rate is only a portion of the total reported.
Remember that deaths from all types of flu added together are lower in the
U.S. this year than from the four previous "non pandemic" years before. (5,13)
3.) Flu vaccines provide little or no protection from the flu.
Vaccination is claimed to prevent the spread of influenza, protect individuals
from acquiring the disease, and do so to a high degree of efficacy.
Unfortunately, the majority of scientific studies do not support these claims.
In fact, meta analyses ("master studies") that look at large numbers of
scientific studies and their outcomes, show the opposite. Influenza vaccine is
minimally or not at all effective for most age groups. Here is how the numbers
break down.
In children under two:
In children under the age of two, influenza vaccines are no more effective
than placebo. (15)
One meta analysis evaluating fifty-one published studies with 294,159
observations found "no efficacy" in children under the age of two. (16) The
authors conclude that "It was surprising to find only one study of inactivated
vaccine in children under two years, given current recommendations to
vaccinate healthy children from six months old in the USA and Canada."
Simply put, the authors question why the U.S. is targeting children under the
age of two for vaccination when the studies show the vaccine to be ineffective
in this age group.
In children over two:
The same meta analysis found influenza vaccines effective 33% of the time in
children over the age of two. (16) Followed to it's logical conclusion, this
means the flu vaccines are ineffective 67% of the time in children over the
age of two.
Another study found influenza vaccine ineffective up to age 5. (17)
In healthy adults:
A meta analysis evaluating 25 studies conducted on 59,566 adults age 14-40
found a mere 6% decrease of clinical influenza in those vaccinated. The
conclusion: "Universal immunization of healthy adults is not supported by the
results of this review." (18)
The recent update to this study, pooling 38 published studies encompassing
66,248 healthy individuals aged 16 to 65 years, found that "serological flu"
(lab numbers) were reduced but actual cases of flu were not reduced. This meta
analysis concluded that improvements in overall flu rates in those vaccinated
"was extremely modest." (19)
In seniors:
Seniors over age 70 account for 75% of all flu-related deaths. Since 1980, the
vaccination rate in seniors has increased from 15% to 65% but the death rate
from flu has not declined. The authors conclude that "the evidence is
insufficient to indicate the magnitude of a mortality benefit, if any, that
elderly people derive from the vaccination program." (20)
Contrary to popular belief, studies have found that secondary pneumonia in
seniors is not decreased by flu vaccination, and that reduction of mortality
through influenza vaccination has been greatly overestimated in this age
group. (21,22)
5.) "Fast track" approval of flu vaccines, especially H1N1, leaves safety
questions unanswered.
"Fast track" approval means that influenza vaccines do
not have to go through the normal regulatory procedures. The H1N1 vaccine
approval was especially fast because of the "pandemic" designation. One of the
approved 4 vaccines was approved after testing in only 221 people for 21 days.
(23) Another was approved after testing on 175 adults for 21 days. (24).
The World Health Organization (WHO) admits that people who get vaccinations
will be the "field testers" of their safety. From the WHO website:
"Time constraints mean that clinical data at the time when pandemic vaccines
are first administered will inevitably be limited. Further testing of safety
and effectiveness will need to take place after administration of the vaccine
has begun. (Author’s italics)
... On the positive side, mass vaccination campaigns can generate significant
safety data within a few weeks. (Author’s italics) (25)
In other words, we won't know the safety of these vaccines until we vaccinate
millions of people (45 million is the U.S. "target" for October) (26,27); the
side effects experienced by those vaccinated will be the "safety data."
The U.S. Government conferred immunity from prosecution to drug manufacturers
of the H1N1 vaccine in July 2009. (28)
6.) Vaccines May Be More Dangerous than the Flu Itself.
In 1976, 200 soldiers at Fort Dix were stricken with the flu, with one
reported death. A pandemic was declared and nearly 40 million people in the
U.S. received the 1976/H1N1 vaccine before the campaign was stopped due to an
increase in Guillain-Barré syndrome, a paralytic autoimmune disease. (29)
More than 500 cases of Guillain-Barré syndrome were reported, 25 of which
resulted in death. This "pandemic that wasn't" never spread beyond Fort Dix.
(30)
In a recent statement by the The American Academy of Neurology, experts said
they don't expect the 2009 H1N1 vaccine to increase risk of Guillain-Barré
syndrome or other autoimmune disease but they acknowledged that this is a
concern with any pandemic vaccine. (31)
Mild short-term reactions to the vaccine can include soreness, redness, or
swelling at vaccination site, low grade fever, runny nose, headache, chills,
tiredness/weakness and body aches and pains. (32) These symptoms are very much
like the flu itself.
Life-threatening allergic reactions (anaphylaxis) and Guillain-Barré syndrome
(a paralytic autoimmune disease) can also occur. (33)
These short-term side effects of influenza vaccination are easier to observe
because of their close proximity to vaccination, beginning within minutes to
several weeks. Long-term and/or cumulative effects of vaccinations are more
difficult to monitor, and questions remain about the long-term safety of
vaccines.
For example, the incidence of Alzheimer's disease in adults and autism in
children has skyrocketed in the last several decades. These rates are
continued to increase. (34,35)
The cause of these increases is not known. Some camps maintain that these
neurological disease escalations may be caused by vaccinations, especially
since many vaccines still contain mercury, aluminum, formaldehyde and other
neurotoxic compounds. (36-39)
The US government, CDC, FDA, and drug manufacturers claim there is no
correlation between vaccines and these diseases, (40-43) although many
question the quality of evidence used to draw this conclusion. (44,45)
7.) "Herd Immunity" Remains Speculative
"Herd immunity" (community immunity) is the belief that if a portion of
society gets vaccinated, weaker members of "the herd" who do not respond
satisfactorily to the vaccine (children under two and seniors over 65) will be
protected from the flu because those around them have been vaccinated. Much
evidence contradicts the concept of "herd immunity." (46-49)
If healthcare workers get vaccinated, they purportedly decrease the risk of
influenza in their high-risk patient, hence the "heavy push" that borders on
mandate for health care workers to receive the vaccine. One large meta
analysis found "no high quality evidence that vaccinating healthcare workers
reduces the incidence of influenza or its complications in the elderly in
institutions." (50)
Conclusions
My purpose in presenting these statistics and studies is to assist the reader
in drawing independent conclusions about the true risk of H1N1 flu and
advisability of vaccination for same.
We are each responsible for our own "due diligence" when making decisions
concerning our health, although many people defer to the media and government
for their directives.
Here are the points I see from these studies and statistics:
- The safety and effectiveness of H1N1 vaccines has not been proven.
- The transmissibility of H1N1 flu is small and the severity mild compared
to seasonal flu.
- My risk of getting the H1N1 flu is small; my risk of dying from this flu
is quite small and no greater than for any seasonal flu.
- Flu vaccines confer little if any protection from influenza viruses in my
age group.
- There is much conflicting "proof" that by getting a vaccination, I help
make others around me safer through "herd immunity."
- There are known short-term and possibly unknown long-term side effects
from vaccines.
All things considered, I'm going to pass on the H1N1 flu vaccine. I believe
there are far safer, better-proven methods to increase my resistance to H1N1
and make sure I have a mild case of it (as most cases are) if I do contract
the flu.
References:
1.) WHO Pandemic Phase Descriptions and Main Actions by Phase. http://www.who.int/csr/disease/influenza/GIPA3AideMemoire.pdf
2.) WHO Website: Pandemic (H1N1) 2009 - update 67. 20 September 2009. http://www.who.int/csr/don/2009_09_25/en/index.html
3.) Center for Excellence in Disaster Management and Humanitarian Assistance.
Researchers say new form of malaria poses threat to humans. Sep 11, 2009.
4.) Michael L. Tapper, MD, Chair. Seasonal and Pandemic Influenza: What You
Need to Know About Prevention and Management.Medscape CME; Sept. 29 2009.
5.) Centers for Disease Control (CDC). 2008-2009 Influenza Season Week 37
ending September 19, 2009. http://www.cdc.gov/flu/weekly
6.) López-Cervantes M, Venado A, Moreno A, Pacheco-Domínguez RL, Ortega-Pierres
G.On the spread of the novel influenza A (H1N1) virus in Mexico. J Infect Dev Ctries. 2009 Jun 1;3(5):327-30.
7.) Miller, Mark; Viboud, Cecile; Simonsen, Lone; Olson, Donald R.; Russell,
Colin. Mortality and morbidity burden associated with A/H1N1pdm influenza
virus: Who is likely to be infected, experience clinical symptoms, or die from
the H1N1pdm 2009 pandemic virus? Version 2. PLoS Currents Influenza. 2009 Aug
26 [revised 2009 Sep 2]:RRN1013.
8.) Michaelis M, Doerr HW, Cinatl J Jr. An Influenza A H1N1 Virus Revival -
Pandemic H1N1/09 Virus.Infection. 2009 Sep 18. [Epub ahead of print]
9.) Gallaher WR. Towards a sane and rational approach to management of
Influenza H1N1 2009. Virol J. 2009 May 7;6:51.
10.) Senanayake SN. A pandemic that's not bird flu? Pigs might fly. Med J Aust.
2009 Jul 6;191(1):38-40.
11.) World Health Organization website: http://www.who.int/csr/disease/swineflu/frequently_asked_questions/levels_pandemic_alert/en/index.html3
12.) Daniel J. DeNoon. First Doses of H1N1 Vaccine Coming Soon. Medscape
Today, September 21, 2009.
13.) "2009 H1N1 Flu Situation Update - September 11, 2009". CDC. 2009-09-11.
http://www.cdc.gov/h1n1flu/updates/091109.htm. Retrieved 2009-09-30.
14.) Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Bacterial coinfections
in lung tissue specimens from fatal cases of 2009 pandemic influenza A (H1N1)
- United States, May-August 2009. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2009 Oct
2;58(38):1071-4.
15.) ##K## Smith S, Demicheli V, Di Pietrantonj C, Harnden AR, Jefferson T,
Matheson NJ, Rivetti A. Vaccines for preventing influenza in healthy children.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2006 Jan 25;(1):CD004879.
16.) ##L## / Jefferson T, Rivetti A, Harnden A, Di Pietrantonj C, Demicheli V.
Vaccines for preventing influenza in healthy children. Cochrane Database Syst
Rev. 2008 Apr 16;(2):CD004879.[## no efficacy in children under 2 33]
17.) ##M## Szilagyi PG, Fairbrother G, Griffin MR, Hornung RW, Donauer S,
Morrow A, Altaye M, Zhu Y, Ambrose S, Edwards KM, Poehling KA, Lofthus G,
Holloway M, Finelli L, Iwane M, Staat MA; New Vaccine Surveillance Network.
Influenza vaccine effectiveness among children 6 to 59 months of age during 2
influenza seasons: a case-cohort study. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2008
Oct;162(10):943-51.
18.) ##N## Demicheli V, Rivetti D, Deeks JJ, Jefferson TO. Vaccines for
preventing influenza in healthy adults. Cochrane Database Syst Rev.
2004;(3):CD001269.
19.) ##O## Jefferson TO, Rivetti D, Di Pietrantonj C, Rivetti A, Demicheli V.
Vaccines for preventing influenza in healthy adults. Cochrane Database Syst
Rev. 2007 Apr 18;(2):CD001269.
20.) ##P## Simonsen L, Taylor RJ, Viboud C, Miller MA, Jackson LA. Mortality
benefits of influenza vaccination in elderly people: an ongoing controversy.
Lancet Infect Dis. 2007 Oct;7(10):658-66.
21.) ##Q## Eurich DT, Marrie TJ, Johnstone J, Majumdar SR. Mortality reduction
with influenza vaccine in patients with pneumonia outside "flu" season:
pleiotropic benefits or residual confounding? Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2008
Sep 1;178(5):527-33. Epub 2008 Jun 12.
22.) ##R## ackson ML, Nelson JC, Weiss NS, Neuzil KM, Barlow W, Jackson LA.
Influenza vaccination and risk of community-acquired pneumonia in
immunocompetent elderly people: a population-based, nested case-control study.
Lancet. 2008 Aug 2;372(9636):398-405.
23.) ##S## Greenberg M, Lai M , Hartel G., et al. Response after One Dose of a
Monovalent Influenza A (H1N1) 2009 Vaccine — Preliminary Report. New Eng J
Med. September 10, 2009.
24.) ##T## Clark T, Pareek M, Hoschler K, Dillon H, et al. Trial of Influenza
A (H1N1) 2009 Monovalent MF59-Adjuvanted Vaccine — Preliminary Report.New Eng
J Med. September 10, 2009.
25.) ##U## WHO Website: Safety of pandemic vaccines: Pandemic (H1N1) 2009
briefing note 6. http://www.who.int/csr/disease/swineflu/note
s/h1n1_safety_vaccines_20090805/en/index.html
26.) ##V## Daniel J. DeNoon. H1N1 Flu Vaccine Fast-Tracked to September? WebMD
Health News, July 17, 2009.
27.) ##W## Daniel J. DeNoon. First Doses of H1N1 Vaccine Coming Soon. Medscape
Today, September 21, 2009.
28.) Federal Register. Vol. 74, No. 121. Thursday, June 25, 2009.
http:edocket.access.gpo.gov/2009/pdf/E9-1494 8.pdf
29.) ##Y### Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). General
Questions and Answers on Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS).September 14, 2009.
http://www.cdc.gov/h1n1flu/vaccination/gbs_qa.htm
30.) ##Z## United Stated Dept. of Health and Human Services. http://www.hhs.gov/nvpo/pandemics/flu3.htm
31.) Gandey A. Report New Cases of Guillain-Barré After H1N1 Flu Vaccine.
Medscape Medical News, September 1, 2009.
32.) ##AB## Influenza Division, National Center for Immunization and
Respiratory Diseases. Prevention and Control of Seasonal Influenza with
Vaccines Recommendations of the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP),
July 24, 2009 / 58(Early Release);1-52.
33.) ##AC## Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).Seasonal Flu Shot
Questions & Answers. Accessed Oct. 7, 2009. http://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/qa/flushot.htm
34.) Hebert, LE; Scherr, PA; Bienias, JL; et al. “State-specific projections
through 2025 of Alzheimer’s disease prevalence.” Neurology 2004;
62:1645.
35.) U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES. Vital and Health
Statistics: Mortality Trends for Alzheimer’s
Disease, 1979–91. Series 20: Data From the National Vital
Statistics System No. 28. Jan 1996. http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/series/sr_20/sr
20_028.pdf
36.) AF / AFLURIA Manufactured by CSL Limited: Package insert:
http://www.fda.gov/downloads/BiologicsBloodVaccines/Vaccines/ApprovedProducts/UCM182401.pdf
37.) AG / Influenza A (H1N1) 2009 Monovalent Vaccine Live, Intranasal:
http://www.fda.gov/downloads/BiologicsBloodVaccines/Vaccines/ApprovedProducts/UCM182406.pdf
38.) Novartis Vaccine (Fluvarin):
http://www.fda.gov/downloads/BiologicsBloodVaccines/Vaccines/ApprovedProducts/UCM182242.pdf
39.) sanofi pasteur 10 September 2009_v0.3 449/454 Influenza A (H1N1) 2009
Monovalent Vaccine:
http://www.fda.gov/downloads/BiologicsBloodVaccines/Vaccines/ApprovedProducts/UCM182404.pdf
40.) Centers for Disease Control and Prevention: Immunization Safety and
Autism
Thimerosal and Autism Research Agenda. Last updated – January 30, 2009.
Accessed online 10-07-09: http://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/autism/documents/vaccine_studies.pdf
41.) Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Vaccine Safety:
Measles, Mumps, and Rubella (MMR) Vaccine. December 23, 2008. Accessed online
10-07-09 http://www.cdc.gov/vaccinesafety/updates/mmr_vaccine.htm
42.) Food and Drug Administration. Thimerosal in Vaccines. Website accessed
10-07-09. http://www.fda.gov/BiologicsBloodVaccines/SafetyAvailability/VaccineSafety/ucm096228.htm#saf
43.) Karen Midthun, M.D. Concerns Regarding a Potential Link Between Vaccines
and Autism. FDA News and Events, April 26, 2001. FDA Testimony before
the House Committee on Government Reform. Accessed 10-07-09 http://www.fda.gov/NewsEvents/Testimony/ucm115226.htm
44.) ROBERT F. KENNEDY JR. Deadly Immunity. Rolling Stone. Posted Jun 20,
2005.
45.) Cal-Oregon Vaccinated vs. Unvaccinated Survey. Generation Rescue,
PORTLAND, OR, Sep 25. Accessed 10-07-09 http://www.generationrescue.org/survey.html
46.) Glanz JM, McClure DL, Magid DJ, Daley MF, France EK, Salmon DA, Hambidge
SJ. Parental refusal of pertussis vaccination is associated with an increased
risk of pertussis infection in children. Pediatrics. 2009 Jun;123(6):1446-51.
47.) Cheek JE, Baron R, Atlas H, Wilson DL, Crider RD Jr. Mumps outbreak in a
highly vaccinated school population. Evidence for large-scale vaccination
failure. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1995 Jul;149(7):774-8.
48.) Briss PA, Fehrs LJ, Parker RA, Wright PF, Sannella EC, Hutcheson RH,
Schaffner W. Sustained transmission of mumps in a highly vaccinated
population: assessment of primary vaccine failure and waning vaccine-induced
immunity. J Infect Dis. 1994 Jan;169(1):77-82.
49.) Sutter R.W, Patriarca P, Cochi SL, Pallansch MA, et al. Outbreak of
paralytic poliomyelitis in Oman: evidence for widespread transmission among
fully vaccinated children. The Lancet, Volume 338, Issue 8769, Pages 715 -
720, 21 September 1991.
50.) Thomas R, Jefferson T, Demicheli V, Rivetti D. Influenza vaccination for
healthcare workers who work with the elderly. Cochrane Database of Systematic
Reviews, Issue 3, 2009. |
